CHIPBY KINETIC CARVING
CNC · Hobbyist · Information · Platform
Return to Kinetic Carving
Projects · Businessintermediate~2 min read

Batch production

Short answer

In batch work, setup time per part becomes the number that matters, not cutting time. A fixture that loads in ten seconds instead of five minutes changes the economics of the whole job more than any feed rate ever will.

What changes at quantity

One-offBatch of fifty
Design timeDominantNegligible per part
Setup per partOnce, and it does not matterDominant. Fifty times whatever it is.
Cutting timeFeels significantMatters, and less than setup
Tool lifeIrrelevantA real cost, and a mid-run failure risk
Material yieldBarely mattersNesting efficiency is real money
FinishingOften the largest timeUsually still the largest time

Fixtures

The single biggest lever. A fixture that locates a blank in one motion turns a five minute setup into a ten second one. Over fifty parts that is four hours.

  • Locating pins so a blank drops into exactly one position.
  • A machined pocket the blank sits in, cut on the machine itself so it is in the machine's own coordinates.
  • Quick clamping: cam clamps, toggle clamps, or a vacuum, rather than screws.
  • Cut the fixture on the machine, and do not move it afterwards. Then its position is known exactly.
  • Keep the fixture. Label it with the job it belongs to. The reorder will come.
The test for whether a fixture is worth building
Multiply the time it saves per part by the number of parts you will make this year, including the reorder you are not counting on. Fixtures almost always pay for themselves faster than people expect, and they also make every part identical, which matters more than the time saving.

Nesting

  • Fit as many parts per sheet as the geometry allows, and remember the offcut has value too.
  • Keep enough material between parts for the tool plus a margin, or the sheet loses rigidity.
  • Cut inner features on all parts first, then the profiles. The sheet is stiffest while it is whole.
  • Plan the profile order so the sheet stays supported as long as possible. The last few parts on a heavily cut sheet are the ones that chatter.
  • Hold the whole sheet, not just its edges. See workholding.

Tool life

In a one-off, a bit that dulls at the end is a non-event. In a fifty part run, a bit that dulls at part thirty means twenty bad parts you may not notice until after.

  • Start every production run with a fresh cutter.
  • Track roughly how many parts a bit gives you in that material, and change it before that number.
  • Inspect parts periodically through the run rather than at the end.
  • Keep a spare of every bit the job needs. Running out mid-run costs a whole setup.

Where the time actually goes

People optimise the cutting because that is the part the machine does visibly. In a real production run the order is usually:

  1. Finishing. Sanding, applying finish, waiting for it to dry, second coats.
  2. Setup and part handling, multiplied by the quantity.
  3. Cutting.
  4. Design, which is nearly zero once it is done.

So if you want a batch to go faster, look at your finishing process and your fixturing before you look at feeds and speeds. A spray setup or a drying rack often buys more than any machine change.