CHIPBY KINETIC CARVING
CNC · Hobbyist · Information · Platform
Return to Kinetic Carving
Troubleshooting · The machineintermediate~3 min read

The job takes far too long

Short answer

Most excess time is a finishing pass sweeping a small tool at a fine stepover over areas that never needed it, or a toolpath made of thousands of tiny segments the machine has to decelerate for. Both are fixable without losing quality.

Symptom

A job that takes dramatically longer than expected, or longer than the CAM estimate, or longer than the same job used to take.

Check
first
Which toolpath is taking the time? Most CAM shows an estimate per operation. If one operation is 80 percent of the total, that is the only one worth optimising, and it is usually the finishing pass.

Most likely causes

  1. Fine finishing pass over the whole modelMost common in 3D
    A small tool at a fine stepover sweeping flat background is the classic waste. Restrict it to detail. See 3D carve time.
  2. Toolpath made of thousands of tiny segmentsMost common in 2D
    The machine decelerates for each one and never reaches the programmed feed. Usually traced vectors. See vector troubleshooting.
  3. Roughing with a tool that is too smallCommon
    Removal rate scales hard with diameter. Rough with the biggest tool that fits.
  4. Stepover far smaller than the finish requiresCommon
    Halving the stepover roughly doubles the time. Calculate the scallop you actually need.
  5. Conservative feed rateCommon
    Check the chipload. Many people are running feeds well below what the machine can do.
  6. Low acceleration configurationOccasional
    The machine cannot reach its programmed feed on short moves. Real and worth checking.
  7. Many retracts and repositioning movesOccasional
    Time spent in the air. Some CAM options control this directly.
  8. Using a ball nose to roughOccasional
    It removes far less material per pass than a flat end mill.

Diagnostic steps

  1. Read the per-operation time in CAM and find the one operation that dominates.
  2. Watch the machine for a minute on that operation. If it never reaches its programmed feed and sounds like it is stuttering, the toolpath is segment-bound. If it runs smoothly and is simply covering a lot of ground, the stepover or the tool size is the lever.
  3. Compare the finishing area to the detail area. If the fine pass covers the whole model and the detail is a fifth of it, there is your time.
  4. Check the chipload on the roughing pass. A conservative feed is often a third of what the machine can hold.

Fixes, ranked by what actually helps

  1. Restrict the fine finishing pass to the areas that genuinely have fine detail. Largest single saving in 3D work, at no cost in quality.
  2. Level flat areas with a flat end mill instead of sweeping them with a ball nose.
  3. Rough with a bigger tool. Finishing removes the evidence.
  4. Clean up the vectors. Faster and better looking at the same time.
  5. Increase the stepover to a scallop you can sand out in five minutes.
  6. Raise the feed rate if the chipload allows, which it often does.
  7. Deeper roughing passes if the machine can hold them.
What does not help
Raising the RPM does nothing for run time at all. It only changes the chipload, usually for the worse. Feed override mid-job does shorten the job, but it raises the chipload above what the settings were built around; use it deliberately, in small steps, while watching the chips and listening, and put the new feed into the toolpath next time rather than leaving the override as a habit.

Why it happens

CAM estimates assume the machine runs at the programmed feed everywhere, and it never does: every direction change costs a deceleration and an acceleration, and a toolpath made of thousands of short segments is nothing but direction changes. Finishing passes multiply that by covering the whole surface at a stepover chosen for the finest detail on it. Neither is a fault in the machine. Both are decisions made in CAM, which is where the time comes back from.

Prevention

  • Set the finishing stepover from a target scallop, and restrict fine passes to the areas that need them.
  • Clean up vectors before toolpathing, every time, and check node counts on anything traced.
  • Rough with the largest tool that fits, and let a finishing pass remove the evidence.
  • Run the chipload calculator before accepting a feed rate that feels safe.
Read next
3D CarvingWhy 3D carves take so long, and what actually helpsWhere the hours go in a 3D carve, ranked by how much time each change buys back and what it costs in quality.CuttingMachining timeWhy jobs take longer than the estimate, what actually drives carve time, and how to cut it without cutting quality.3D CarvingScallop height and stepover for 3D finishingThe ridges a round cutter leaves between passes, the geometry that sets their height, and the time cost of halving them.SoftwareVector troubleshootingOpen vectors, duplicates, self-intersections, node explosions and bad traces. How to find them and how to fix them.